Debunking email hoaxes and exposing Internet scams since 2003!

Hoax-Slayer Logo Hoax-Slayer Logo

DividerDivider
Home    About    New Articles    RSS Feed    Subscriptions    Contact
DividerDivider


Site Navigation










Issue 105 - August 2010 - Page 20

Pages in this month's issue:
  1. Mars, Earth - Closest Approach in Recorded History
  2. Falsely Attributed Quote - A Norman Rockwell Moment
  3. Telstra Bill Account Update Phishing Scam
  4. Scammers Pose as Microsoft Tech Support Workers to Hijack Computers
  5. Laptop Fire Death Warning Email
  6. Verified By Visa Banking Incident Phishing Scam
  7. St. Augustine Find - Huge Eastern Diamondback Rattlesnake
  8. Free Blackberry Storm for Forwarding Hoax
  9. Five Headed Cobra Hoax Images
  10. AOL Update Billing Information Phishing Scam
  11. Kevin Rudd Fire the Cattle Guards Hoax
  12. Resignation Of Barack Obama Virus Hoax
  13. Decorative Magnets on Refrigerators - Cancer Warning Hoax
  14. Knob Face Trojan Worm Warning Message
  15. Face Book Promotion Advance Fee Scam
  16. BlackBerry RIM Inactive Account Hoax
  17. Circulating Request - Help Pooja Find Her Parents
  18. Black in the White House Virus Hoax
  19. 1954 Home Computer Hoax
  20. Debbie Shwartz Charity Hoax

Issue 105 Start Menu

Previous Article

Debbie Shwartz Charity Hoax

Outline
Email claims that AOL will help Debbie Shwartz, a struggling single mother, by donating money every time an email is forwarded to 12 people.



Brief Analysis
This message is a pointless hoax. The claims in the message are untrue. The message is just one in a long line of similar hoaxes that claim that money will be donated in exchange for forwarding an email. Any message that makes such a claim is virtually certain to be a hoax and should not be sent on to others.

Detailed analysis and references below example.

Bookmark and Share


Enter your email address to subscribe to the Hoax-Slayer Newsletter:




Last updated: 19th July 2010
First published: 25 July 2003
Article written by Brett M. Christensen
About Brett Christensen and Hoax-Slayer


Example
Subject: WE ALL THINK OUR LIVES ARE HARD!!!! READ BELOW TO KNOW HOW LUCKY WE REALLY ARE

~~IF YOU DELETE THIS YOU ARE HEARTLESS!!~~

Dear Reader

I am a single mother of four kids: ages five, three and a half, 17 month, and two week old baby girl. God has blessed me with three beautiful, healthy children. Until recently things were going great for us, even though we struggled financially at times (my part-time job was not enough to support us).

Then, the tragedy struck on January 13th. My oldest, Matt, got hit by a car while playing outside. ( The driver never got fined - it was a hit and run). After agonizingly long weeks of hospitalization, we did not think he would live but thank godness is he alive right now ... but barely. He is still in the hospital in the comatose condition. Doctors say he will be a vegetable for the rest of his live, for as long as he lives and even if he does come out of the coma - his brain is too damaged for him to lead a normal life. My insurance coverage run out and I can't afford hospital bills. Right now I owe a hospital over 500,000 dollars so far.

Shortly, after the accident has happened, my 87 year old grandmother, with whom I was really close (she raised me as a child), suffered a stroke and could not live on her own anymore. I took her in.

All that happened while I was pregnant with Carissa. Because of all this severe stress that I've been through, Carissa was not only a premie but was born with Down's syndrome as well as chronic colitis. She is also missing fingernails on her right hand. She is in the hospital as well because she needs to be monitored 24/7. Right now I am at the lowest point of my life: I don't have a job - taking care of three sick family members that are so dear to me is a full time job - I can't afford to pay for my tiny appartment, my car got taken away because no payment, not to mention the debt with a hospital!

I know you are not obligated to do anything: you are free to delete this email without giving it a second thought, but please listen to the cry from mothers heart! We had worked out a deal with AOL where for every 12 forwards I will get 15 cents. Please, don't harden your heart, send this email to everyone on your list. This is crucial for our survival!! God bless you all!

Sincerely,

Debbie Shwartz




Detailed Analysis
This widely circulated email forward supposedly tells the sad story of a single mother named Debbie Shwartz who is trying to look after sick family members on her own while struggling to make ends meet financially. According to the message, you can help Debbie simply be forwarding the email on to as many people as possible. The message claims that AOL has agreed to pay Debbie 15 cents every time the email is forwarded to 12 other people.

However the message is a pointless hoax. AOL will certainly not donate money based on how many times an absurd email is forwarded. You can rest assured that sending on this email will do nothing whatsoever to help a family in need. In fact, this message is just another variant in a long line of very similar - and equally absurd - hoaxes that claim that a specified company or charitable organization will help a sick child or family by donating money in exchange for forwarding an email.

Any message that makes such a claim is certain to be a hoax. No legitimate company or organization is ever likely to participate in such a ridiculous fundraising scheme. Firstly, even if a company such as AOL did agree to such a plan, there is in fact no reliable or ethical method of tracking the journey of such a charity email as it moves its way to countless inboxes around the world. Therefore, it would be impossible to calculate in any meaningful way how much money such a forwarding campaign would actually raise. Secondly, these hoaxes never include any sort of time frame or other limiting factors in the supposed charity campaign messages. Therefore, given that many of these hoaxes circulate for years on end, the participating company might find itself obligated to hand over very large amounts of money. No organization is ever likely to willingly place itself in such a precarious position.

The Debbie Shwartz version of the hoax has now been circulating continually for seven years and would have easily wracked up hundreds of thousands of forwards. If AOL was really donating 15 cents per 12 forwards, Debbie would actually be doing quite well by now with all of her major financial problems well and truly behind her. The 2010 version of this aging hoax tacks on a photograph depicting a young mother with her son. Since this image may have been added to the hoax email without the permission or knowledge of the woman in the photograph, I have not included it here.

If you receive this hoax message, or one of its many variants, please do not forward it to others. And please help stop the spread of such pointless nonsense by informing the sender that the message is a hoax.

Bookmark and Share



References
Charity Hoaxes
Absurd Charity Hoaxes Continue



Previous Article

Issue 105 Start Menu

Pages in this month's issue:
  1. Mars, Earth - Closest Approach in Recorded History
  2. Falsely Attributed Quote - A Norman Rockwell Moment
  3. Telstra Bill Account Update Phishing Scam
  4. Scammers Pose as Microsoft Tech Support Workers to Hijack Computers
  5. Laptop Fire Death Warning Email
  6. Verified By Visa Banking Incident Phishing Scam
  7. St. Augustine Find - Huge Eastern Diamondback Rattlesnake
  8. Free Blackberry Storm for Forwarding Hoax
  9. Five Headed Cobra Hoax Images
  10. AOL Update Billing Information Phishing Scam
  11. Kevin Rudd Fire the Cattle Guards Hoax
  12. Resignation Of Barack Obama Virus Hoax
  13. Decorative Magnets on Refrigerators - Cancer Warning Hoax
  14. Knob Face Trojan Worm Warning Message
  15. Face Book Promotion Advance Fee Scam
  16. BlackBerry RIM Inactive Account Hoax
  17. Circulating Request - Help Pooja Find Her Parents
  18. Black in the White House Virus Hoax
  19. 1954 Home Computer Hoax
  20. Debbie Shwartz Charity Hoax