Debunking email hoaxes and exposing Internet scams since 2003!


Hoax-Slayer Logo Hoax-Slayer Logo

DividerDivider
Home    About    New Articles    RSS Feed    Subscriptions    Contact
DividerDivider
Bookmark and Share









Issue 125 - February 2012 (2nd Edition) - Page 10

Caged Pigs Protest Message

Issue 125 Start Menu

Previous Article            Next Article

Outline
Circulating message that features a photograph depicting pigs confined to very small cages claims that the photograph was taken on an American factory farm and that the pigs are kept in the tight cages so that they will fatten up more quickly because their movement is restricted.



Brief Analysis
The photograph is genuine but the description is inaccurate. The photograph was taken not in the United States, but in China several years ago. Moreover, the pigs have been placed in cages not to fatten them, but to transport them to market. Certainly, the treatment of pigs and other farm animals has raised great concern among people from all around the world. However, to be effective, messages protesting such treatment need to contain accurate and up-to-date information.

Bookmark and Share
Detailed analysis and references below example.





Last updated: 3rd February 2012
First published: 3rd February 2012
Article written by Brett M. Christensen
Research by David White, Brett Christensen
About Brett Christensen and Hoax-Slayer


Example
Caged Pigs in China

This very sad & disturbing photo was taken at a US factory farm. These poor pigs are confined to cages that severely limit their movement so that they will fatten up quickly. Please share this photo with as many people as possible so we can increase awareness of the importance of buying certified organic products & preventing the unnecessary suffering of all farm animals.



Detailed Analysis
This message, which features a photograph depicting several pigs cruelly confined in very tight cages, is currently circulating rapidly via social media. According to the message, the photograph was taken on a factory farm in the United States. The message claims that the pigs are kept in the tiny cages to restrict their movement so that they will fatten more quickly.

The photograph itself is genuine. However, the description that comes with the photograph contains false information. The photograph was not taken on a farm in the United States. And the pigs are not kept in the tiny cages shown in the photograph to fatten them up more quickly.

In fact, the photograph was taken in May 2007, not in the US, but in China's Guangdong province. The same photograph appears on the Reuters news pictures website with the following caption:
Pigs are prepared for transportation to a market in Baizhu county of Zhaoqing, southern China's Guangdong province May 8, 2007. A mysterious disease has killed thousands of pigs in China's southern Guangdong province and authorities have disinfected affected farms, markets and abattoirs, several Hong Kong newspapers reported on Monday. REUTERS/Stringer (CHINA) CHINA OUT
Certainly, the treatment of pigs and other farm animals has raised great concern among people from all around the world. And farm sows are often kept in tiny cages called gestation crates for months at a time while they are pregnant. A February 2012 Huffington Post article that discusses a Humane Society of the United States report on some factory farms notes:
For four months while pregnant, pigs are confined in gestation crates -- two-foot by seven-foot metal cages. They're moved to another crate to give birth, after which they're impregnated again and put back into a gestation crate to repeat the cycle. This happens again and again, until the animals either die in their crates or can no longer breed at a profitable rate and are sent to slaughter. Each animal may spend up to three years locked in a crate, virtually immobilized for nearly her entire life.
Social media can be a powerful and effective means of raising awareness about issues such as the mistreatment of farm animals. However, to be effective, social media messages need to contain accurate and up-to-date information. Otherwise, as in this case, they will rapidly lose credibility and effectiveness as people realize that the information they contain is inaccurate.

Bookmark and Share

References
Pigs are prepared for transportation
HSUS Documents Animal Abuse at Major Pork Producers



Previous Article            Next Article

Issue 125 Start Menu

Pages in this month's issue:
  1. Protest Message - Live 'Tortoise' Souvenirs Sold in China
  2. Absurd Warning Claims That Monster Energy Drink Logo Hails Satan
  3. Facebook Photograph of Man Riding Motorbike Over Children's Hands
  4. IRS Penalty Phishing Scam
  5. Hoax - Share Photo to Raise Money to Help Abused Puppy
  6. Urban Legend - Rapist Hides in Back Seat at Garage
  7. Hoax - Indian Woman Gives Birth to Eleven Babies at Once
  8. Praying Mother and Son Rock Formation
  9. Pharmacy Spam Emails Purport to be From YouTube
  10. Caged Pigs Protest Message
  11. Protest Message Rails Against New Facebook Timeline
  12. Bogus Warning - Adobe Flash Player Update Messages in Zynga Games are Trojans
  13. Refugee Monthly Allowance From Australian Government Hoax
  14. Baby With Skin Rash Facebook Share Hoax
  15. Derbyshire Fairy Hoax