Debunking email hoaxes and exposing Internet scams since 2003!


Hoax-Slayer Logo Hoax-Slayer Logo

DividerDivider
Home    About    New Articles    RSS Feed    Subscriptions    Contact
DividerDivider
Bookmark and Share









Issue 149 - March 2013 (1st Edition) - Page 6

Contact Lens BBQ Warning Hoax

Issue 149 Start Menu

Previous Article            Next Article

Outline
Message claims that staring at a BBQ fire while wearing contact lenses can cause the lenses to melt and lead to permanent blindness.

Contact Lens BBQ Hoax

© Depositphotos.com/Olga Miltsova



Brief Analysis
The claims in the warning are false. The story is a long running urban legend that has haunted work places around the world since the 1960's. Reposting false and misleading health information such as this will serve no good purpose.

Example:(Submitted, December 2006)
Those who wear contact lenses, remove them when you have to attend a BBQ party or whatsoever that got to do with flames... I heard a horrible true story about contact lenses.... It happened to a 21 year old guy, he wore a pair of contact lenses during a barbecue party. While, he was barbecuing, he stared at the fire charcoals. After a few seconds, he started to scream for help and moved rapidly, jumping up and down. No one in the party knew why... When he arrived at the Hospital, the doctor said he'll be blind permanently courtesy of the contact lenses that he had worn. Contact lenses are made by plastics, and the heat from the charcoal melted his contact lenses.

So, tell all your friends.....DO NOT WEAR CONTACT LENSES WHERE OVERHEATING AND FLAMES ARE CONCERNED... pass this message to all your friends

Detailed Analysis
According to this email forward, a young man who stared at a BBQ fire became blind when the contact lenses he was wearing melted onto his eyes. However, the information in this foolish "warning" is completely unfounded.




Years ago, I worked in a Sydney metal products factory. At the time, there was a story circulating among workers that a welder in a nearby factory had gone blind after a welding flash melted his contact lenses to his corneas. The rumour turned out to be untrue. In fact, the story is a long running urban legend that has haunted work places around the world since the 1960's. An American Welding Society Fact Sheet(.pdf) notes:
Since 1967, the American Welding Society has received reports concerning welders who have claimed to have had contact lenses fused to their eyes, either by the heat of the arc or by microwave radiation. Not one of these reports has been substantiated, and safety bulletins issued by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the National Safety Council (NSC) have all indicated such incidents could not possibly have occurred.
This BBQ warning message appears to be a mutated version of the older welding urban legend. Like the legend, it has no basis in fact. If an everyday occurrence such as staring at a BBQ fire for just a few seconds was enough to melt contact lenses and cause serious eye injuries, then there would undoubtedly be thousands of well documented cases of such injuries. If standing close to normal BBQ coles was enough to melt lens, then household heaters, stoves, and a variety of other common heat sources would presumably have the same effect. However, I could not locate even one credible report of such an injury. Given that there is at least 125 million contact lens wearers worldwide, it is vastly improbable that such injuries would have somehow escaped the notice of medical authorities and the news media. Quite obviously, if contact lens where so apt to cause blindness when exposed to commonly occurring heat sources, then they would have been removed from the market years ago.

There are potential risks associated with contact lens use, but these risks are generally concerned with possible eye infections and corneal ulcers and having nothing to do with lenses fusing to eyeballs due to heat exposure. Using lenses as instructed and following common sense contact lens safety guidelines can minimize such risks.

Because contact lens may, in some cases, "complicate eye safety", there is also some controversy over the use of contact lens in the workplace. Again, however, these potential safety issues are in no way related to eye injuries caused by "melting" lenses.

Forwarding errant nonsense such as this is nothing more than scaremongering and will serve no good purpose.

Last updated: February 21, 2013
First published: 19th December 2006
Written by Brett M. Christensen
About Hoax-Slayer

References
American Welding Society: CONTACT LENS WEAR
FDA: Contact Lens - Risks
Safety Tips for Contact Lens Wearers
OSH Answers: Contact Lenses at Work

Previous Article            Next Article

Issue 149 Start Menu

Pages in this issue:
  1. Lakeside Attempted Abduction Warning
  2. The Tale of the Racist Airline Passenger
  3. Circulating Post Claims US Charity CEO's Overpaid
  4. Bogus Warning - 'Talking Angela' Threat to Children
  5. WhatsApp 'Servers Really Full' Hoax
  6. Contact Lens BBQ Warning Hoax
  7. Facebook Hoax - Pay to become Gold Member or All Your Documents will be Made Public
  8. Facebook Team Security 2013 Phishing Scam - 'Last Warning - Your Account Will Be Disabled'
  9. Friend Request Facebook Ban Warning - 'Facebook Jail'
  10. Will Responding to a Question about Facebook Group Usage Cause Future Posts To Be Censored?
  11. O2 Shop 'View Bill Online' Phishing Scam
  12. Images Purporting to Show Jamie Bulger Killer Jon Venables Circulate Online