Debunking email hoaxes and exposing Internet scams since 2003!

Hoax-Slayer Logo Hoax-Slayer Logo

DividerDivider
Home    About    New Articles    RSS Feed    Subscriptions    Contact
DividerDivider


Site Navigation










Issue 158 - July, 2013 (2nd Edition) - Page 22

Does a Viral Image Depict a Monkey Saving a Puppy From An Explosion?

Issue 158 Start Menu

Previous Article            Next Article

Outline
Circulating message claims that an attached picture shows a monkey saving a small puppy from a factory explosion in China.



Brief Analysis
The claims in the message are untrue. The picture circulated in different contexts for several years before the explosion referenced in the message. Earlier descriptions claim that the monkey was saving the dog from a tsunami or other natural disaster. Some versions claim that the monkey was stealing the dog. However, Dani Weiss, the photographer who took the picture, explains that the monkey was tethered and simply carrying the puppy around and playing with him.

Bookmark and Share
Example

During a dangerous factory explosion that occurred in China, a Monkey was recorded on the camera saving a puppy from the explosion site, He held the dog as he ran out of the factory. If animals can instinctively show compassion and kindness to each other, So can we.
Monkey Pup

Image credit: Dani Weiss Photography


Detailed Analysis


According to a message that circulates via social media outlets, an attached image depicts a monkey saving a puppy in the aftermath of a factory explosion in China. The message suggests that, if animals can instinctively show compassion for others, humans should do likewise.

However, the description that comes with the image is not accurate. The explosion mentioned in the message apparently references a massive factory blast that occurred in eastern China in 2010. The above version of the monkey message began circulating soon after this blast.

But, in fact, the very same image has circulated since at least 2006 with a host of alternative descriptions. Some versions claim that the monkey was stealing the puppy, perhaps with nefarious and violent motives. Others claim that the monkey was saving the pup from different natural and man made disasters, including the Japanese tsunami and various floods, fires and explosions.

The photo, along with another shot depicting the same two animals appears in an album on the Dani Weiss Photography website. In response to my query about the image, Dani notes:

Yes I took this photo. This image was taken in a village in the Hilltribe county in Thailand. The monkey was tied up around the waist. He basically was carrying around the puppy and playing with him. Not much more. It looks bizarre but nothing awful seemed to be happening. Never understood why the monkey was tied up.

Thus, while the picture is certainly an engaging one, it does not depict a monkey saving a puppy from an explosion in China or any other disaster. It should also be noted that unscrupulous like-farmers have used the image and false description as a means of amassing likes for their bogus Facebook Pages.

Bookmark and Share

Last updated: July 4, 2013
First published: July 3, 2013
By Brett M. Christensen
About Hoax-Slayer

References
Monkey Saves Puppy, But Not From China Explosion
Monkey puppy thief
Monkey Saving Dog from Japan Tsunami
Dani Weiss Photography - Album
Dani Weiss Photography
Dani Weiss Photography - Facebook
Photo of Monkey Rescuing Puppy a Hoax
Facebook Like-Farming Scams



Previous Article            Next Article

Issue 158 Start Menu

Pages in this issue:
  1. Capri Sun Mold Warning
  2. False Child Abduction Alert - 'Lilly Snatched From Surrey'
  3. Gas Saving Tips - Are They Really Saving You Anything?
  4. China Food Imports - Is It Really That Simple?
  5. Jury Duty Phone Scam Warning
  6. Myth - Ice Water Can Cause Dangerous Bloating in DogsD
  7. Amazon 'Important Message From Security Center' Phishing Scam
  8. Hoax: Facebook to Start Charging This Summer
  9. Kmart Australia Giveaway Like-Farming Scam
  10. Do Water Filled Zip-Lock Bags with Added Pennies Keep Flies Away?
  11. Photos of Old Car Collection Found in Portugal Barn
  12. Faux Image - Mounted Police Officer Riding Giant Dog
  13. Expedia Travel Itinerary Malware Email
  14. 'Google Account Hacked' Text Message Scam
  15. Completely Pointless and Misleading 'Facebook Privacy Notice'
  16. Hoax - Pope Benedict XVI Resigned Papacy to Convert to Islam
  17. Wonga.com 'Account Error' Phishing Scam
  18. Hoax Warning Claims Deadly Swine Flu Epidemic in South Africa
  19. Australian Government Withdrawing Funds From Inactive Accounts Warning
  20. 'Facebook Has Sent You a Message' Pharmacy Spam
  21. Pepsi Cola Bottling Company 'Grant Compensation' Advance Fee Scam
  22. Does a Viral Image Depict a Monkey Saving a Puppy From An Explosion?
  23. Advance Fee Scammers Using Cloned FB Accounts To Gain Victims
  24. South African 'Mighty Men' Conferences Racial Integration Hoax
  25. Did Samsung Pay a $1 Billion Fine to Apple in 5 Cent Coins?
  26. Browser and Operating System Survey Scam
  27. Circulating Message Falsely Accuses Pictured Man of Being a Human Trafficker