Debunking email hoaxes and exposing Internet scams since 2003!

Hoax-Slayer Logo Hoax-Slayer Logo

DividerDivider
Home    About    New Articles    RSS Feed    Subscriptions    Contact
DividerDivider


Site Navigation










Issue 158 - July, 2013 (2nd Edition) - Page 24

South African 'Mighty Men' Conferences Racial Integration Hoax

Issue 158 Start Menu

Previous Article            Next Article

Outline
Circulating message claims that South Africa's ANC has proposed a bill that would force the organizers of the popular Christian "Mighty Men" conferences to ensure that 70% of conference tickets were sold to native Africans in a move to advance racial integration.

Mighty Men Conferences quota hoax

© Depositphotos.com/ Adam Hicks



Brief Analysis
The claims in the message are false. No such bill has been proposed. The story is a satirical piece that gained popularity after it was published via the user-generated section of the News24 website in November 2011. The writer later published a follow-up article noting the satirical - and entirely fictional - nature of the piece.

Bookmark and Share
Example
Subject:  SA Minister Beauty Kumalo has spoken ..... SIMPLY UNBELIEVABLE!

Minister Beauty Kumalo has spoken
This was on NEWS 24.
 
In a new initiative to advance racial integration in South Africa, the ANC government has proposed a bill to Parliament which states that all Angus Buchan's “Mighty Men” conferences must be representative of the population of South Africa. The proposal includes legislation that will force the sellers of these tickets to
first sell 70% of all tickets to native Africans, before any tickets may be sold to whites / settlers.

Mrs Beauty Kumalo, Chairperson of Africans for Jesus, has commended the initiative by the ANC government.

"Too long real South Africans (blacks) have been excluded from having the same privileges as the whites in serving our Lord Jesus Christ from
Nazareth (now relocated to heaven). Apartheid has given the white man better churches, Bibles and theologians which gives them an unfair advantageof reaching heaven. We require equal rights for all Christians. We are tired of the racist white man trying to keep us out of heaven."

Detailed Analysis


According to a message that circulates via email and social media websites, South Africa's ANC government has proposed a bill that would ensure that attendance at South African evangelist Angus Buchan's "Mighty Men" Christian conferences are representative of South Africa's population. Supposedly, the proposed legislation would force ticket sellers to first sell 70% of conference tickets to native Africans before whites and settlers could buy any tickets. The message purportedly quotes ANC minister "Beauty Kumalo" as claiming that because of Apartheid, white South Africans have enjoyed better Christian resources than black South Africans and therefore have an "unfair advantage" with regard to reaching heaven. The message claims that the proposed bill will address such issues and advance racial integration in South Africa.

However, the claims in the message are utter nonsense. The ANC has made no such proposal.  The story began life as a satirical piece and its author never intended it to be taken seriously.

In November 2011, contributor Gerhard Nel published the story via MyNews24, the user-submitted section of South Africa's News24 website. This section allows readers to upload their own stories to the website.  In this case, Gerhard Nel uploaded the above, clearly satirical, story in an effort to highlight what he considers the silliness of racial quotas. He never intended the piece to be taken seriously and he certainly did not expect that it would generate so much angst and debate or circulate for so long. The piece quickly escaped its original home and began circulating in other contexts.

In a follow-up article in which he explains his motivation and offers apologies to those who may have been offended by the article, Nel notes:

On 3 November 2011 News24 published an article that I wrote, titled “ANC Propose Quota System for Mighty Men Conferences.” The article was a satirical piece and clearly ridiculous and silly to its core. In the months that passed I have received mixed feedback on it. Some praised me, some insulted me and some have even threatened me. It is with concern that I have noticed that some people, mostly on the religious right, have taken this clearly bogus silly piece of writing and turned it into Gospel. Even my wife has received angry emails in the line of “How dare The ANC do this?”

The whole point I was trying to make in the article was to show just how silly racial quotas is. At no time was this article intended to advance racial tensions in any way whatsoever. In the article I applied the same logic that some people in our ANC led government want to apply to our sporting teams and in the work place, to religion. I truly believe like religion, sport should be enjoyed by all whom wish to participate in it and in the end you will be rewarded by your actions.

An earlier version of the piece appeared in a 2009 post on the Spear The Mighty blog.
 
"Mighty Men" organizer Angus Buchan also dismissed the message as a hoax, noting on his Facebook Page:

“NO TRUTH IN HOAX” (Minister Beauty Khumalo)

I NEED TO CONFIRM THAT THERE IS NO TRUTH IN A RECENT HOAX BEEN FOUND IN EMAILS AND OTHER MEDIA BLOGS. WE DO NOT APPROVE OF OR APPRECIATE THE DISREGARD THIS PERSON HAS FOR OUR BELOVED COUNTRY.

WE ARE SAD AT THE IRRESPONSIBLE AND PATHETIC JOKE MADE OF BLACK / WHITE RATIO AT MMC’S OR ANY OTHER EVENT – ON THE CONTRARY, WE BELIEVE WE ARE AT THE THRESHOLD OF A MIGHTY REVIVAL OF ALL PEOPLE, NO MATTER THEIR RACE, CULTURE OR GENDER.

GOD BLESS, ANGUS BUCHAN

Thus, as has happened many times before, a fictional story intended only as satire has travelled far from its context and many recipients have thus mistaken it for a genuine news article.

It is always wise to verify information you receive via social media posts or email before sharing it with others.

Bookmark and Share

Last updated: July 2, 2013
First published: July 2, 2013
Written by Brett M. Christensen
About Hoax-Slayer

References
The Mighty Men Conferences
No Truth in hoax email
Mighty Men Conference Quota System Does Not Exist
ANC propose quota system for Mighty Men conferences



Previous Article            Next Article

Issue 158 Start Menu

Pages in this issue:
  1. Capri Sun Mold Warning
  2. False Child Abduction Alert - 'Lilly Snatched From Surrey'
  3. Gas Saving Tips - Are They Really Saving You Anything?
  4. China Food Imports - Is It Really That Simple?
  5. Jury Duty Phone Scam Warning
  6. Myth - Ice Water Can Cause Dangerous Bloating in DogsD
  7. Amazon 'Important Message From Security Center' Phishing Scam
  8. Hoax: Facebook to Start Charging This Summer
  9. Kmart Australia Giveaway Like-Farming Scam
  10. Do Water Filled Zip-Lock Bags with Added Pennies Keep Flies Away?
  11. Photos of Old Car Collection Found in Portugal Barn
  12. Faux Image - Mounted Police Officer Riding Giant Dog
  13. Expedia Travel Itinerary Malware Email
  14. 'Google Account Hacked' Text Message Scam
  15. Completely Pointless and Misleading 'Facebook Privacy Notice'
  16. Hoax - Pope Benedict XVI Resigned Papacy to Convert to Islam
  17. Wonga.com 'Account Error' Phishing Scam
  18. Hoax Warning Claims Deadly Swine Flu Epidemic in South Africa
  19. Australian Government Withdrawing Funds From Inactive Accounts Warning
  20. 'Facebook Has Sent You a Message' Pharmacy Spam
  21. Pepsi Cola Bottling Company 'Grant Compensation' Advance Fee Scam
  22. Does a Viral Image Depict a Monkey Saving a Puppy From An Explosion?
  23. Advance Fee Scammers Using Cloned FB Accounts To Gain Victims
  24. South African 'Mighty Men' Conferences Racial Integration Hoax
  25. Did Samsung Pay a $1 Billion Fine to Apple in 5 Cent Coins?
  26. Browser and Operating System Survey Scam
  27. Circulating Message Falsely Accuses Pictured Man of Being a Human Trafficker