Debunking email hoaxes and exposing Internet scams since 2003!

Hoax-Slayer Logo Hoax-Slayer Logo

DividerDivider
Home    About    New Articles    RSS Feed    Subscriptions    Contact
DividerDivider
Bookmark and Share









Muslim Sign in Houston Mall Protest Message - The Martyrdom of Imam Ali

Outline
Protest email claims that a sign posted on the door of a Muslim owned shop in Houston in September 2009, honoured one of the September 11 hijackers who flew the aircraft into the World Trade Center.



Brief Analysis
This sign was indeed posted on the door of a shop at Harwin Central Mall in Houston, Texas in September 2009. However, aside from the date, the sign has no relationship whatsoever with the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. Imam Ali, the person named on the offending sign, was not one of the September 11 hijackers as claimed in the protest message. In fact, Imam Ali is a holy man much venerated in the Islamic religion and he is viewed by Muslims as the successor to Muhammad himself. Imam Ali died hundreds of years ago in the year 661 AD.

Bookmark and Share
Detailed analysis and references below example.



Scroll down to submit comments
Last updated: 3rd June 2010
First published: 3rd June 2010
Article written by Brett M. Christensen
About Brett Christensen and Hoax-Slayer


Example
Subject: Fw: Fwd: Sign in Houston Mall

What enrages me is that Americans would shop there!!!! Now, this is stepping over the line.

IN CASE YOU HAVE NOT SEEN THIS. READ CAREFULLY...........

This is so "Unbelievable"....

In Houston ...

Harwin Central Mall: The very first store that you come to when you walk from the lobby of the building into the shopping area Had this sign posted on their door. The shop is run by Muslims. Feel free to share this with others.

(Transcript of sign)
"We will be closed on Friday, September 11, 2009 to commemorate the martyrdom of Imam Ali (A.S.)"

Houston Mall Sign

Imam Ali flew one of the planes into the twin towers.

Nice huh?
Try telling me we're not in a

Religious war!

THIS HAS NOT BEEN AROUND....SO MAKE SURE IT DOES!




Detailed Analysis
Imam Ali
Imam Ali was not one of the 9/11 hijackers but rather a Muslim holy man who died in the year 661 AD
This outraged protest message, which circulates via email, blogs and social networking websites, decries the 2009 posting in a Houston Mall of a sign which it claims payed homage to one of the hijackers responsible for the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States. The message includes a photograph of the sign, which read "We will be closed on Friday, September 11, 2009 to commemorate the martyrdom of Imam Ali (A.S.)". According to the message, Imam Ali, the person identified as a martyr on the offending sign, was one of the terrorists who flew a plane into the World Trade Center.

The photograph itself is genuine and depicts a real sign that was hung on the door of the "Perfume Planet" store in Houston's Harwin Central Mall in September 2009 by its Muslim store manager, Imran Chunawala.

However, the claim in the protest message that Imam Ali was one of the 9/11 hijackers is an outright lie. There is no person of that name recorded on the FBI list of 9/11 hijackers. In fact, Imam Ali -"Imam" is simply a word for a Muslim religious leader - is a very important historical figure in the Islamic religion and is considered to be the imam who succeeded the Prophet Muhammad. Imam Ali died, not in a hijacked aircraft in 2001, but many centuries ago in the year 661 AD. The imam died on the 21st day of Ramadan of that year. In an unfortunate coincidence, the 21st day of Ramadan happened to fall on September 11 in the year 2009, thus causing a great deal of misunderstanding among mall visitors and -subsequently - the public at large courtesy of the Internet.

An article about the misunderstanding caused by the sign published on Houston news outlet, khou.com notes:
Store manager Imran Chunawala was stunned because the holiday had nothing to do with 9 /11. Then he realized what happened. This year a key Ramadan Holiday happened to fall on 9/11. "We did not explain enough in the sign because that is the exact same sign we put up every year on this particular day for this particular reason," said Chunawala. He apologized for the confusion and put up a new sign thoroughly explaining the martyr they were honoring died in 661 AD.
Given the date of the store's holiday, it is not at all surprising that the sign caused so much confusion and consternation. That said, it seems clear that the store manager meant no disrespect, even though the placing of the sign with such wording at that particular time of the year was certainly ill conceived. Although the initial confusion caused by the sign is certainly understandable, it is hard to imagine how Imam Ali's name was misidentified in the subsequent protest email as one of the 2001 hijackers other than by a deliberate and wilful act of deception.

Bookmark and Share

References
FBI Announces List of 19 Hijackers
Imam Ali
Houston store's decision to honor Muslim martyr causes misunderstandings
Store's sign causes controversy

Last updated: 3rd June 2010
First published: 3rd June 2010
Article written by Brett M. Christensen
About Brett Christensen and Hoax-Slayer

Similar Articles:
Obama Muslim Stamp - USPS Muslim Holiday Stamp Release Protest Message
Australian Flag Lapel Pin Story - Response to Muslim Woman's Checkout Criticism
Cadbury Products - Halal Certification Authority Logo Protest Email