Debunking email hoaxes and exposing Internet scams since 2003!


Hoax-Slayer Logo Hoax-Slayer Logo

DividerDivider
Home    About    New Articles    RSS Feed    Subscriptions    Contact
DividerDivider
Bookmark and Share












Giant New Orleans Crocodile Hoax Email

Summary:
Email claims that a giant 21-foot crocodile was found swimming the flooded streets of Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans (Full commentary below.)



Status:
Real photographs, false location

Example:(Submitted, September 2005)
Subject: Wow, Now this is a big crocodile

Believe it or not!

Now this is a Crocodile!

This crocodile was found in New Orleans swimming down the street. 21 FT long, 4,500 lbs, around 80 years old minimum.

Specialists said that he was looking to eat humans because he was too old to catch animals. This crocodile was killed by the army last Sunday at 3:00 pm, currently he is in the freezer at the Azur hotel. The contents of its stomach will be analyzed this Friday at 2:30pm

New Orleans Crocodile Hoax Image 1

New Orleans Crocodile Hoax Image 2

New Orleans Crocodile Hoax Image 3





Commentary:
The photographs that arrive with this email forward supposedly depict a giant man-eating crocodile caught swimming the flooded streets of New Orleans in the wake of destruction caused by 2005's Hurricane Katrina. The photographs are real. However, they were not taken in New Orleans. The images were displayed on various websites and began circulating around the Internet via email and online forum posts long before Hurricane Katrina struck.

Apparently, the photographs were actually taken in Pointe Noire, Republic of the Congo, during 2003. The original email message is very similar to the current version, except that the prankster has relocated the action to New Orleans rather than Africa. According to an article discussing the original message on About.com, information about this giant crocodile was published on July 17, 2003 in La Semaine Africaine, a French language Congolese magazine.

Also, it appears that the length, weight and age of the reptile are exaggerated in both the original Pointe Noire version of the email and the 2005 New Orleans mutation.

The About.com article notes that the magazine story records the crocodile as measuring 5 meters (around 16 feet) and weighing 850 kilos around (1,874 lbs). The animal's age is estimated to be around 50 years rather than 80 years as claimed in the messages.

The animal depicted is a Nile crocodile. Nile crocodiles are found across a large portion of Africa (but certainly not the New Orleans region) and do indeed grow to enormous sizes. According to an article on the Crocodilian Species website, Crocodylus niloticus has an average adult length of around 5 meters (about 16 feet) and has been reported as reaching 6 meters (around 19 feet) in rare cases. The article notes:
There are dubious reports of 7 m animals having existed, but these are hard to verify.
A Wikipedia entry about Nile crocodiles concurs:
Seven meter (23 ft) and larger specimens have been reported, but since gross overestimation of size is common these reports are suspect.
Thus, while the photographs depict a real animal, it is probably not as large as claimed in the email message and it was certainly not "found in New Orleans swimming down the street".

Bookmark and Share

References:
The Monster Crocodile of Pointe-Noire
Crocodilian Species - Nile Crocodile (Crocodylus niloticus)
Wikipedia: Nile Crocodile

Last updated: 27th January 2010
First published: September 2005
Article written by Brett M. Christensen
About Brett Christensen and Hoax-Slayer